Monday, August 05, 2013

No Worries Here About Peralta's Suspension

Ken Rosenthal of Fox Sports has reported that Tigers shortstop Jhonny Peralta is accepting without appeal his 50-game suspension for Performance Enhancing Drug use.  This comes to no surprise to anyone who has been following baseball news the last few weeks.  With 50 games left in the Tigers season, this means that Peralta would be eligible to come back for the last three games in Miami and also the playoffs if they make it.

The question is whether the Tigers will want him back at all.  The Giants did not want Melky Cabrera back last year, so it's possible the same could happen here.  However, I sense the Tigers have a good relationship with Peralta and I suspect they would be open to re-instating him on the roster.  It does not seem likely that he would come back as a starter though.  The Tigers acquired new shortstop Jose Iglesias at a big price (promising young outfielder Avisail Garcia), not only as insurance for Peralta, but also to be their shortstop of the future.

The Tigers will miss Peralta's bat, but not his defense.  I have never been happy with the Tigers trio of statues on the infield at first, shortstop and third base, even with the excellent offense they provide.  Miguel Cabrera is the best hitter in baseball, Prince Fielder will probably get back to being one of the best and Peralta was an above average shortstop offensively.  The best starting rotation in baseball deserves some infield defense though and they haven't beeen getting enough it.

It is especially important to have infielders with range behind extreme ground ball pitchers Doug Fister and Rick Porcello.  Peralta is not a horrible defender.  He is very sure handed but has little range and a weak arm.  We have already been given a sampling of what Iglesias can do at third and he should be able to do even more at shortstop.  I'm happy to give up Peralta's bat for a gold glove caliber shortstop if he can hit at all. 

How well, this new arrangement works out depends on Iglesias' bat.  So far, in the majors, he has batted .277/.328/.360 in 328 at plate appearances.  If he can do that with his defense, it will be more than acceptable.  Even something like .250/.310/.340 would be acceptable.

There are no guarantees, but the acquisition of Iglesias was not a desperation move.  The hope is that he will be the starting shortstop in Detroit for the next few years and that Peralta will be forgotten quickly. It's going to be fun to watch and I bet that Fister and Porcello agree. 


  1. Get your facts straight about Peralta's defense. Read this:

  2. Mr Anonymous, I read BYB all the time and am aware of how Mr. O'Kennedy feels about Peralta. I respect his opinion a lot, but I like Peralta on the Tigers less than he does. I think Peralta is sure handed and probably average overall, but has very poor range. With Cabrera at third and two extreme ground ball pitchers, I want to see a stronger defender at shortstop.

    As for getting facts straight, I've given plenty of facts about Peralta's defense in the past and don't need to repeat them every post. Try this:

    I stand by my opinion that he is sure handed but has poor range.

    Sure, they'll miss his bat, but he was playing over his head this year and chances are he would have faded down the stretch. I think the Tigers will be fine without him.

  3. The worst part is that he could still come back. It would have been nice if the Tigers figured out some way to trade him at any point in time since the original date they signed him, even if it's just his playoff rights for this year.

  4. Hi Lee: So if we see any more of Peralta this year it is as a pitch hitter?

  5. Kevin, if things are going well, I don't think Peralta will be back. I could see him as a bench player especially as a pinch hitter in post season where they go with just 11 pitchers.

  6. It is hard to tell what the future holds. Is Cabrera ever going to be healthy again? We could conceivably need Jhonny at third base. What if Iglesias can't hit at all? I would not entirely rule out that a scenario would unfold in which we are delighted to see Mr. Peralta back.

    1. Very possible, the Tigers do like Peralta arguably as much as anybody if not more. And Iglesias could be very useful as an all-purpose guy that can play a tremendous amount while rotating other guys out. He would only ever play SS or 3B, and if Prince needs a day off then Iglesias can play 3B with Cabby going to 1B.

      So I still hope the Tigers find 2 new potential stars for the future at SS and 2B.

    2. Or he could sub for Cabby, or sub for the other SS, and he could also relegate either Cabby or Fielder to DH and liven up the defense much further. Or they could split DH duty.



Blog Archive


My Sabermetrics Book

My Sabermetrics Book
One of Baseball America's top ten books of 2010

Other Sabermetrics Books

Stat Counter