Saturday, January 05, 2008

Fielding Bible - 2007

This is the fifth part of my series on fielding for 2007. The Table of Contents for the series is listed below:

Basic fielding stats
Converting Zone Rating to something useful
Revised Zone Rating
Probabilistic Model of Range
Fielding Bible
Ultimate Zone Rating
Fan Fielding Survey versus range measures
Outfield arms
Ranking the second basemen
Ranking the shortstops
Ranking the third basemen
Ranking the first baseman
Ranking the center fielders
Ranking the right fielders
Ranking the left fielders
What about catchers?

Before I discuss The Fielding Bible system, I want to direct you to a database which SG has constructed over at the Replacement Level Yankees Weblog. He has put together detailed Zone Rating data from 1987-2007 including translations into runs saved above average. You can find it on the left sidebar of that site under "Fun Stuff". SG obviously put a lot of work into it and it's a valuable resource.

Now back to my analysis...

John Dewan's Fielding Bible plus/minus system has many similar features to Zone Rating (ZR), Revised Zone Rating (RZR) and especially Probabilistic Model of Range (PMR). The system is described briefly on the Fielding Bible web site. The site also has various other excerpts from their 2006 book and they are worth reading because they explain fairly complex concepts quite clearly.

On the web site, they describe how video scouts watch every play of every major league game and record information about location , distance, speed (soft/medium/hard) and type of hit (groundball, liner, flyball, bunt, fliner (somewhere between fly and liner) for each play. It's the same data collection system used for RZR and PMR but the three systems have somewhat different methods of processing the data.

In the Fielding Bible +/- system, each type play (e.g soft hit ground ball hit into the hole between short and third) has a difficulty which is determined by how many times major league fielders convert that play into an out. For example, if that play was made 30% of the time, the a player gets a score of +.70 for making that play. If he doesn't make that play, he gets a -.30. All the scores on all the plays are summed for a player to get his +/- rating. The rating represents how many plays the player made above or below those an average player at his position would make.

So +/- is equivalent to PMAA (plays made above average) which we calculated for all the other systems. As usual PMAA can then be converted to RSAA as described in Chris Dial's article. Also, PMAA and RSAA can be prorated to 150 games to get PMAA/150 and RSAA/150.

There is no Fielding Bible book this year but Baseball Info Solutions did release 2007 data for about half the players - the ten leading fielders and the five worst fielders at each position. The available results for the Tigers in 2007 are summarized in Table 1 below. You can see that the following players were among the 10 best at their positions: Jacques Jones (42 runs saved above average per 150 games), Brandon Inge (+18), Curtis Granderson (+18), and Placido Polanco (+8). Miguel Cabrera (-20) finished among the bottom five third basemen.

Table 2 compares the Tigers on ZR, RZR, PMR and +/-. It can be seen that Jones, Inge, Granderson and Polanco ranked well on all 4 systems and that Cabrera ranked poorly in each case.

Table 1: Plays Made and Runs Saved by Tigers fielders in 2007 according to +/-

Pos

player

Inn

PMAA

RSAA

PMAA/150

RSAA/150

1B

Casey

989

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

2B

Polanco

1,209

10

8

11

8

3B

Inge

1,310

22

18

22

18

3B

Cabrera

1,311

-24

-19

-24

-20

SS

Guillen

1,074

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

SS

Renteria

1,019

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

LF

Monroe

806

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

CF

Jones

645

24

20

50

42

CF

Granderson

1,285

21

18

22

18

RF

Ordonez

1,221

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A



Table 2: Runs Saved Per 150 Games - RZR,ZR, PMR and +/-

PLAYER

RZR

ZR

PMR

+/-

Granderson

34

10

19

18

Jones

24

9

13

42

Inge

13

12

16

18

Polanco

12

4

9

8

Monroe

9

7

-12

N/A

Renteria

5

-9

-4

N/A

Ordonez

-5

10

-3

N/A

Casey

-8

8

-15

N/A

Cabrera

-13

-16

-26

-20

Guillen

-18

-7

-18

N/A

Thursday, January 03, 2008

Probabilistic Model of Range - 2007

This is the fourth part of my series on fielding for 2007. The Table of Contents for the series is listed below:

Basic fielding stats
Converting Zone Rating to something useful
Revised Zone Rating
Probabilistic Model of Range
Fielding Bible
Ultimate Zone Rating
Fan Fielding Survey versus range measures
Outfield arms
Ranking the second basemen
Ranking the shortstops
Ranking the third basemen
Ranking the first baseman
Ranking the center fielders
Ranking the right fielders
Ranking the left fielders
What about catchers?

David Pinto at Baseball Musings finished his Probabilistic Model of Range (PMR) tables for 2007 in November. They can be found by scrolling through in his defense archives. PMR may be the most sophisticated freely available fielding statistic you can find on the internet. It is based on detailed play by play data collected by Baseball Info Solutions.

Here is how it works: The difficulty of turning a ball in play into an out is determine by several parameters: location of ball, how hard the ball is hit (soft, medium, hard), type of ball hit (e.g. ground ball, fly ball, line drive), handedness of batter and pitcher and ballpark. The expectation that a particular ball in play is turned into an out is determined by aggregation of this data for all games played in 2007.

Pinto then determined, for each fielder, how may balls were in play when he was on the field, how many he should have been expected to turn into outs and how many he actually turned into outs. The idea is that good fielders will record more outs than expected and poor fielders will record fewer outs than expected. David Pinto, himself, explains the whole PMR system in more detail on YouTube.

For example, 3,724 balls were in play when Placido Polanco was on the field. Based on all the parameters and data for all fielders, it was determined that Polanco should have turned approximatelly 409 balls into outs. In actuality, he turned 420 balls into outs. So he made 11 more plays than would be expected by the typical shortstop (PMAA). If you look at the PMR archives, you will see that the fielders are ranked according to "ratio". For example, Polanco had a 102.67 ratio (outs/predicted outs) which means that he made 2.67% more plays than average.

PMR is similar to zone rating (ZR) and revised zone rating (RZR) but there are some differences. One advantage the PMR system has over ZR and RZR is that it treats balls in different parts of the zone differently. Pinto considers some balls in a zone to be more difficult to reach than others and he takes this into consideration in his algorithm.

PMR has received some criticism for including pop ups for infielders whereas the zone rating systems do not. Some feel that catching pop ups doesn't really have a lot to do with range. I can see their point but I also think there are some fielders who get to a lot of pop ups that others might not have reached. I guess I'm on the fence on that one. One last thing to remember is that different collection systems are used. ZR uses data from STATS, Inc wheras RZR and PMR use data from BIS.

As we did for ZR and RZR, PMAA can be translated into runs saved above average (RSAA) using Chris Dial's method. As usual, PMAA and RSAA can easily be prorated to 150 games (PMAA/150 and RSAA/150). The results for Tigers in 2007 are shown in Table 1 below.

In Table 2, PMR is compared to ZR and RZR on RSAA/150. Using PMR, Curtis Granderson was 19 runs better than average, Brandon Inge (16), Jacque Jones (13) and Polanco (9). All four of them have been above average on all three measures so far. Craig Monroe (-12) is below average for the first time. The systems disagree on Sean Casey and Magglio Ordonez. Miguel Cabrera and Carlos Guillen rated poorly on all three systems.

Table 1: Plays Made and Runs Saved by Tigers fielders in 2007 according to PMR

Pos

player

Inn

outs

pred outs

PMAA

RSAA

PMAA/150

RSAA/150

1B

Casey

989

198

212

-14

-11

-18

-15

2B

Polanco

1,209

420

409

11

8

12

9

3B

Inge

1,310

400

380

20

16

20

16

3B

Cabrera

1,311

330

362

-32

-25

-32

-26

SS

Renteria

1,019

361

365

-4

-3

-5

-4

SS

Guillen

1,074

389

408

-19

-14

-24

-18

LF

Monroe

806

166

175

-9

-7

-14

-12

CF

Granderson

1,285

424

402

22

18

23

19

CF

Jones

645

195

187

8

7

16

13

RF

Ordonez

1,221

261

265

-4

-3

-4

-3



Table 2:
Runs Saved Per 150 Games - RZR vs ZR vs PMR

PLAYER

RZR

ZR

PMR

Granderson

34

10

19

Jones

24

9

13

Inge

13

12

16

Polanco

12

4

9

Monroe

9

7

-12

Renteria

5

-9

-4

Ordonez

-5

10

-3

Casey

-8

8

-15

Cabrera

-13

-16

-26

Guillen

-18

-7

-18

Tuesday, January 01, 2008

Revised Zone Rating

This is the third part of my series on fielding. The Table of Contents for the series is listed below:

Basic fielding stats
Converting Zone Rating to something useful
Revised Zone Rating
Probabilistic Model of Range
Fielding Bible
Ultimate Zone Rating
Fan Fielding Survey versus range measures
Outfield arms
Ranking the second basemen
Ranking the shortstops
Ranking the third basemen
Ranking the first baseman
Ranking the center fielders
Ranking the right fielders
Ranking the left fielders
What about catchers?

After John Dewan left STATS and founded Baseball Info Solutions (BIS), he developed a new version of Zone Rating (ZR) which he called Revised Zone Rating (RZR). There are some differences between ZR and RZR. First, ZR uses data collected by STATS while RZR uses data gathered by BIS.

Another important distinction is that RZR separates balls hit outside a fielder's zone from balls inside a fielder's zone. There are a couple of reasons why it is useful to analyze balls outside the zone separately from balls hit inside the zone. Plays outside of a player's zone are typically more difficult than plays within the zone. Also, although making a large number of plays outside your zone is probably a good thing in most cases, it is possible that a player might be making some plays that a teammate could have handled just as easily. Thus, I think it can be valuable to look at the numbers of plays made inside and outside the zone before combining them.

One more difference between ZR and RZR is that RZR does not give a player extra credit for having both an assist and a putout on a double play. Being able to turn double plays is a valuable skill but a statistic that is mostly a measure of range should not credit two plays to a player that really made one. Thus, I think this is a good improvement.

The Hardball Times database includes the following statistics: Balls In Play within a fielder's zone (BIZ), Plays made in the zone (PLAYS), RZR or percentage of BIZ converted into outs, and plays made outside the zone (OOZ). Justin Inaz who writes the blog "On Baseball and the Reds" has developed an algorithm which combines RZR and OOZ and translates these numbers into plays made above average (PMAA) and runs saved above average (RSAA).

Justin first calculates the proportion of plays made per BIZ for all players combined at each position and considers that to be the expected ratio of plays made in zone (EXPPRATIO). From that, he calculates for each player, the plays made in zone above/below the MLB average (PIZ AA):

PIZ AA = PLAYS - BIZ*EXPPRATIO

He then assumes that the number of balls hit into the zone is correlated with the number of balls hit outside the zone. Considering that assumption, he calculates OOZ per BIZ for all players combined at each position (EXPORATIO). From that, he gets for each player, the plays made outside the zone above/below the MLB average (OOZ AA):

OOZ AA = OOZ - BIZ*EXPORATIO

Finally, he combines plays made inside the zone and plays made outside the zone to get PMAA:

PMAA = PIZ AA + OOZ AA

That can then be translated into Runs Saved Above Average (RSAA) the same way we did with Zone Rating. The results for the Tigers in 2007 are shown in the table below. Justin included results for all players in 2007 in a google spreadsheet.

Using Jacque Jones as an example, Table 1 is read as follows:

INN = Jones played 645 innings in centerfield
RZR = Converted 92.5% of balls hit in zone to outs
OOZ = 35 out of zone plays made
PIZ AA = Given his opportunities, he made 6 more plays in his zone than the average CF
OOZ AA = 8 more plays made out of zone than average
PMAA = 14 more total plays made than average
RSAA = 12 runs saved above average
PMAA/150 = 29 plays made per 150 games above average
RSAA/150 = 24 runs saved per 150 games above average

Table 2 compares RSAA/150 for Revised Zone Rating versus Zone Rating. The first thing to notice is that ZR appears to a bit more conservative than RZR That is, looking at all MLB players, RZR has higher highs and lower lows than ZR. The median still falls right around zero for both measures though as it should. There are some noticeable differences for individual players. First, Renteria is above average on RZR (+5) and below average on ZR (-9). Conversely, Magglio Ordonez is below average on RZ (-5) and above average on ZR (+10). Sean Casey's numbers (-8, 8) also are different for the two measures. This is why it is important to look at more than one range measure.

The way I look at it is that the very good fielders (e.g. Curtis Granderson, Jones, Brandon Inge) perform well on every measure and the poor fielders (e.g Miguel Cabrera, Carlos Guillen) perform poorly on every measure. The fielders who fall between very good and poor will go up and down according to the measure. I'm going to show you a couple of more measures. Then I will take the average of all the measures for each player and rank all the fielders in baseball by position.


Table 1: Plays Made and Runs Saved by Tigers fielders in 2007 according to RZR

POS

PLAYER

INN

RZR

OOZ

PIZ AA

OOZ AA

PMAA

RSAA

PMAA/150

RSAA/150

1B

Casey

989

.707

22

-5

-2

-8

-6

-10

-8

2B

Polanco

1209

.868

39

12

2

14

11

15

12

3B

Inge

1310

.712

63

12

4

16

12

16

13

3B

Cabrera

1311

.627

50

-17

-0

-17

-13

-17

-13

SS

Renteria

1019

.815

49

-0

5

5

4

6

5

SS

Guillen

1074

.801

36

-5

-14

-20

-15

-24

-18

LF

Monroe

806

.852

34

-1

7

6

5

11

9

CF

Granderson

1285

.921

85

12

27

39

33

40

34

CF

Jones

645

.925

35

6

8

14

12

29

24

RF

Ordonez

1221

.906

29

8

-14

-6

-5

-6

-5



Table 2: Runs Saved Per 150 Games - RZR vs ZR

PLAYER

RSAA/150 (RZR)

RSAA/150 (ZR)

Granderson

34

10

Jones

24

9

Inge

13

12

Polanco

12

4

Monroe

9

7

Renteria

5

-9

Ordonez

-5

10

Casey

-8

8

Cabrera

-13

-16

Guillen

-18

-7

Twitter

Blog Archive

Subscribe

My Sabermetrics Book

My Sabermetrics Book
One of Baseball America's top ten books of 2010

Other Sabermetrics Books

Stat Counter